Tag Archive for 'protective stops'

ROLLS ROYCE – A Lesson Re-learned

Our Rolls Royce trade last week was particularly annoying. We fell for – or rather, didn’t allow enough for,  one of then oldest tricks in the market makers’ armoury.

When it is pretty obvious to all that a stock (in this case Rolls Royce), that has suffered a minor price pullback on some ‘bad’ news, is about to make a recovery the market makers’ trick can be to push the price hard down at the open before they then start buying like fury to lift the price dramatically upwards.

What that does is not only to take out those, like ourselves, who had just opened a Long trade in anticipation of the upmove but also to dissuade others who were about to do the same. This then leaves the market makers with an open ‘Long trade’ goalmouth.

Click on the chart to enlarge it.

Why did we not pay more heed to our instincts and experience that this might happen? The only answer that we can provide is that we were put off entering a lower stop-loss price by the size of the gap when we suggested opening the trade at the 618p price ( on the 9th Nov.).

Our initial instinct was to set the stop at 558p – i.e. under the previous day’s wide-spread low. But to have done that meant a gap below the opening price of some 9.7% and we thought this too large a gap and so settled for the slightly higher stop at 574p. Mistake! Wrong! We should have used our initial analysis or we should have eschewed taking the trade. As it was a 9.7% risk would not have been too out of bounds given that the potential for profit was put at + 22.3%.

We made a mistake and re-learned an old lesson.

Review of the FTSE, S&P, DJIA and Nasdaq Market Indices

The major indices have moved sideways for several weeks now. This is making life a little difficult as it does tend to have an attrition effect on our trading. This is simply because of the up and down whipsawing nature of a sideways moving market which creates an higher incidence losing trades as protective stops are hit.

So we ask ourselves, should we be in this market at all? Would it not be more sensible just to sit this period out on the sidelines and wait for a more positive directional trend to set in?And we answer ourselves by again analysing the trending signals being given by each market index and, again, coming to the conclusion that we should stay in and keep trading.

The main point being that although the risk of a downside move is increasing slightly by the week as the indices fail to make upward progress the fact is that the indices are holding their own, moving sideways, within the overall dominant Uptrend. The very fact that it is an Uptrend indicates that higher prices should continue – even though there will be price consolidations and corrections from time to time.

So, we worry and fret that the next bit of bad news could cause a tumble in share prices but we remain true to the faith that the dominant trend will assert itself and, whilst it is an Uptrend, take share prices higher at some point. Any tumble could be relatively short lived anyway as all of the major indices have potential support levels not far below current prices.

It is an important part of the decision to stay invested and investing that, after such a relatively long time going sideways, the markets are much more likely to pole-vault upwards once they do start to move. The crucial level is, as we have repeated for several weeks now, the 1122 level on the S&P 500. If that is broken to the upside then just watch (and, if invested, enjoy) the resulting rush upwards in share prices in London as well as on Wall Street.

To shorthand the individual stock market reviews here is our view of the potential prices that the markets could move up to, together with the first levels of potential support in the event of a ‘bad news’ reaction –

Market                   last week                                             potential level                                 support level

when Uptrend reasserts                   if market falls

—————       ———————                                    ——————————-                  ———————

FTSE 100         Weak. No progress for 8 wks                         5770                                          5108 (then 4670)

FTSE 250         Weak. No progress for 12 wks                      10600                                          8888 (then 7980)

FTSE SmCap   Weak. Becoming endemic                               2910 (then 3230)                        2425

S&P 500           Stalled at resistance level (1111/1122)            1290                                           1000 (then 940)

DJIA                 Pushing upwards                                           10785 (then 11800)                      9705 (if 10333 fails)

NASD 100        Stalled. 5 wks sideways                                   1827 (then 2040)                         1740 ( then 1629)

Individual market commentary and illustrative charts are available at http://www.sharehunter.com/news/market-review/