Tag Archive for '1929 crash'

‘Quantative Easing’ – its Effect on the Stock Market

Quantitative Easing’ is a euphemism for ‘fake money’. It is a high fallutin’ modern-day term given to the simple, ultimately very costly, old fashioned, last gasp of the culpable politician, resort of printing money.

In the longer term the billions of ‘monopoly’ £1 notes printed under this authoritative sounding term ‘Quantitative Easing’ will doubtless have a serious and deleterious effect on the value of Sterling and on interest rates.

The one thing that it hasn’t done is to reduce the potentially frightful impact of the multi-billion pound sovereign debt of UK Plc. piled up by the incompetents who were, and still are, in charge of our national economy and well being.

In the short term it has served to keep the wolf – in the form of a UK economic collapse – at bay. And that, we have to assume was its main purpose – ahead of an imminent general election!

The other achievement of QE is to delay the reckoning that has to come on the stock market. Our concern remains that now, with the withdrawal of the QE ‘funny’ money, that reckoning may be even harder. There can be little doubt that the stock market’s significant 2009-2010 rally is a direct result of the QE printed pounds. Equally then, there should be little doubt that the ending of QE will have a detrimental effect by removing the prop of so many new pounds.

It is also of concern that having ’shot the QE bolt’ there is nothing left in the politicos’ armoury to prevent the next collapse. But perhaps we display too much naivety as we should not be surprised at the audacious short term fixes that our politicians can magic up.

The concoction of QE has had the effect of encouraging the FTSE to rise to a level from which, if the historical stock pricing pattern continues to be followed, will see it crash down again. We have written several times over the last few weeks of the remarkable, and worrying, similarities that exist between the FTSE now and the Dow Jones index in 1929-32 ( see our Jan 28, 2010 blog below – “Is the Current Market Downturn About to Get Worse – Much Worse??”).

The buyers have slowed down on both the UK and US stock markets (our Momentum Indicator is still declining) and the FTSE 100 index is now, once again, on a cliff edge.

The FTSE has support at the 5100 level area and is clinging to this as we write. If that level fails (and we have to say that it is looking as thought it might) then the FTSE 100 will fall quickly to the 4700 area. And, if the historical price pattern continues in play then the FTSE 100 will be down to 3500 within months.

But whichever way that the market goes there is such huge potential for all of us. If share prices do collapse then we will make hay (profits!) on the downside by short-selling stocks. If the market rallies we will be back buying stocks. What we have to hope is that the current sideways whipsawing movement is overtaken by a definitive move, be it up or down.

Then there is the bonanza opportunity. This will be if/when the market crashes to a final low.

Back in 1932 the ‘Dow’ made a final low at 40.5 . This was down nearly 90% from the Oct. 1929 high and equities became a dirty word. No-one wanted to own equities. Bonds became the flavour of the month and subsequent years. Yet by 1937 the ‘Dow’ had risen to 195 – a rise of some 380% in average share prices. And, because of the ‘buy Bonds’ propaganda most missed that huge profit opportunity.

Dow 1929 - 2010Click on chart to enlarge

So, dear reader, if the FTSE 100 does crash down to the 3500 area later this year we are likely to hear much the same ‘buy Bonds avoid equities’ story but, this time, we – and hopefully you – will be ‘in there’ as soon as the trend change shows itself.

The FTSE 100 Index, weekly -

FTSE 2000- 2010

Click on chart to enlarge.

Is the Current Market Downturn About to Get Worse – Much Worse??

History suggests that it might!

We are becoming increasingly concerned that the 2009-2010 recovery in the FTSE might be ending. There are several signs that suggest this could be starting to happen although, we must add at this point, so far the current correction has to be viewed as nothing more than an overdue reaction to the extent and pace of the 2009-2010 recovery after the 2008-2009 collapse.

We were right when, back in June 2008, we warned of an impending stock market collapse (although we did suggest a 70% fall was on the cards but it actually fell by only (!!) 49% and we are now growing increasingly aware of the possible fragility of the recent recovery and of the potential for another, major, stock market crash.

Please do not think that we are forecasting another crash, we are not, but we are suggesting that it is well to be aware of the potential and so be able to avoid getting caught on the wrong side, should it happen.

Our present concern centres on two aspects; the first we have written about several times and that is the important support/resistance level for the S&P 500 Index which is at 1122. Having pushed its nose above this level the S&P 500 has fallen back to it and is struggling. If it cannot regain the upper ground above 1122 then it is likely to run out of support and fall off, possibly rapidly.

And, as the S&P 500 is the main driver for the London as well as for Wall Street a fall would quickly be replicated on the FTSE (as well as others).

The second centre of concern is the distinct similarities that exist between our current markets and what happened during and after the 1929 Wall Street Crash. This concern is growing and should not be dismissed as fanciful as significant historical trends do repeat from time to time. The similarities that exist look more substantial than the comparisons made over recent months by various economists as to the Great Depression and the West’s current financial tribulations.

We base our analysis purely on technical features of the price actions of the markets and we pay no regard to macro economics.

The chart below shows the S&P 500 Index over the last 2 years (we will come to the FTSE 100 shortly) -

S&P Simple

(Click on any chart to enlarge it)

Note how the index fell by over 50% and then started recovered by 50% of the collapse and then just poked its head above the 1122 and immediately fell back.

Now let’s look at the Dow Jones Industrial Index for the same period. Note how it has done the exactly the same; big rise, big collapse and a recovery of 50% of the collapse and then poking its head above the 10345 resistance level and now has fallen back below it.

Dow - Simple

And the FTSE -

FTSE Simple

Now, we have seen this same pattern – a long rise (over years) followed by a price collapse and then a 50% recovery of the collapse…and that happened with dramatic and long lasting effect in 1929-30. Here is the chart of the Dow for that period.

1929 Wall Street Crash

And you can immediately see what is starting to worry us a little now – that the recovery only just poked its head above the half-way level of the collapse before it crashed back down again. And then it just kept on going down eventually taking out 90% of the value from the 1929 top.

Now, we are not suggesting that there is likely to be anything of that proportion involved in the coming possible correction of the market but we are suggesting that it is entirely possible for the market to follow a similar pattern at least as far as a retest of the March 2009 lows.

The 3 charts below show the potential danger to the S&P 500, the Dow and to the FTSE 100 index if they do continue to follow the same pattern:

S&P - 2010 Collapse

Dow - 2010 pos collapse

FTSE 2010 Collapse

Note in the case of the FTSE, it is still a little above the half-way support/resistance level. This could stand it in good stead, particularly as the current dominant trend is still the Uptrend, but it is a cause of concern that the current correction is gaining impetus and is likely to be greater than any previous correction made during the recovery uptrend since March 2009.

Conclusion:

No definitive change from Uptrend yet but the number of warning signs is slowly increasing. The worry is that, with the markets having thus far followed a very similar path to that established in the 1929-30 period, any continuation of that path will be the cause of major price falls in the coming months.

There is, of course, always the possibility that the markets will break with the historical pattern and make further progress after the current correction has run a short course but it would be wise to do two things -

  1. Be prepared for another crash
  2. Brush up on your Shorting skills

Just in case!

Alan Saunders

Chief Analyst

@ ShareHunter

29th January 2010